Politics : Award Winning Viewpoints from Liberal Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory

Thursday 13 January 2011

Land of my Pilgrim Fathers - Boston Lincolnshire

"We're the forgotten town" says my brother. It's a common refrain as I speak to members of my family. Once the second biggest port in England and a hotbed of radical religious fervour that influenced the world - it is now a traffic clogged backwater. As someone who left the town 22 years ago it seems fitting that nowadays the towns greatest historical legacy is to be known as a place that people escaped. When the Pilgrim Fathers (who were imprisoned there) arrived in America they chose to name their home Boston.

Yet, 'forgotten town' seems an odd label. Over the last few years, for a small market town of only 60,000, Boston has attracted a remarkable amount media attention - none of it good. Firstly, Boston United, the local football team, attracted attention for making illegal payments to players and avoiding tax. United were subsequently relegated three leagues in two years. The chant from the terraces of 'who ate all the pies' was easy to answer because in 2006, Boston was named the fattest town in Britain with 31% of its residents clinically obese.

The growth in its population was not just around the waist. In 2001 96% of the population were regarded themselves as 'white' British. After the expansion of the European Union in 2004, Boston saw its population grow by 25% in just a couple of years. Although wages are very low in the area, migrants from Eastern European countries with even lower wages were were attracted by the prospect of working on the farms and in the food packing and processing factories. According to Refugee Support, 95% of local employers use casual labour and 98% is immigrant labour.  In 2008, Hazel Blears, then Communities Secretary,  confirmed to a Commons Select Committee that one in four people were from Portugal or Eastern Europe and an incredible 65 languages were spoken. 

Much attention, and rightly, has been given to the plight of the new 'Bostonians'. In 2007, The Independent ran a story, 'Immigration: In the town where the gangmaster is king.' Gangmasters are contracted to provide labour for the agricultural and horticultural industry. The Reverend David de Verny, former Chapain to migrant workers, was very critical of the system, "Two hundred years after the official abolition of slavery we are treating foreign workers like slaves. We are only interested in them as economic commodities."

Verny's concerns seem to be borne out by the practices of the gangmasters. The Independent reported they had a 'very holistic approach to "caring" for their workers – getting the wages back by selling them housing, food from their own shop, vodka or hard drugs, or prostitutes. Marta, a 28 year old from Warsaw said, "The gangmaster system rules the town. It is a total disaster. People work for 12 hours, seven days a week, for very little money. All the Poles live together in overcrowded houses paying ridiculous rents to the gangmaster. They travel together and they have no money or time to learn English. What chance do they have?"

Little has been said, however, about the problems that this huge influx of immigrants has brought to the town. Maggie Peberdy of the Citizens' Advice Bureau, noted that, "If you're 50 years old and have been working for the same company for a long time, you're in big trouble. You may be getting slow and a bit arthritic, but the boss can get in a Pole who is younger and faster. He will work seven days a week, at all hours, and he'll be paid piecemeal with no sick pay, no holiday pay, nothing. Unless you accept those terms too you may be out of a job." The immigrants have enabled the producers to keep wages low. 

The strain is being felt in a number of ways. Last year a Boston Headteacher warned that, soon, 60% of pupils will be from immigrant families. A police report in 2006 highlighted that Eastern European 'mafia-style gangsters were organising prostitution. In a stop and check operation, Lincolnshire police found 50 per cent of all drivers were committing an offence and 97 per cent of those were migrant workers. The police noted 'a marked increase in road traffic accidents in this rural area.' Boston had also seen a rapid increase in house prices because gangmasters were buying homes to house their low-paid workers. The council estimated the average two-bedroom house price has risen 400 per cent in six years with the  ‘ghettoisation’ of some areas. 

Advice worker, Maggie Peberdy explains, "There are things you can't talk about because you get accused of racism. "One is housing. There is a myth that they are all young, fit and single, but if you put people like that together in vast numbers they soon stop being single. They make couples, and then babies. They may have to be considered a priority for housing help. Their needs will be perceived as greater than those of local people, who may get upset." As The Independent pointed out, these are the words of someone who has demonstrated a commitment to helping the immigrant population. The Telegraph reported last year that the recession has not seen the migrants returning home. Boston is now officially the fertility capital of Britain with an average of 2.8 babies per woman, thanks largely to the new immigrant families. 

All public services have been put under pressure by the population growth and by the challenges of dealing with people who don't speak English and have different cultural expectations. Remember, this is a rural and very isolated part of the country. When I was at secondary school I was regarded as an ethnic minority for having an Irish grandfather and being a catholic. Don't underestimate what a culture shock this has been for everyone concerned. Current estimates suggest that there are at least 66,000 people living in the borough. Yet government funding is based on the data from the last census which showed 54,000, no wonder services are struggling to cope. In the circumstances, it seems quite an achievement that there has not been more tension in the town. 

Visiting Boston from Bath is a pretty big culture shock, even for someone who was raised in the town. It feels like venturing into a rather dystopian vision of globalised Britain. It is a town that feels deprived. Lacking money, yes, but to a large extent direction and hope. The election, in 2008, of a BNP candidate to the Fenside Ward, on Boston Council again drew the media, but, the BNP's victory, while no doubt reflecting a degree of racial tension, with a poll of just 279 votes on a turnout of 22% it was hardly a racist mandate. What the media missed and is more interesting, I think, is that 25 of the 32 council seats are controlled by independents. There is a general feeling that the mainstream parties just aren't interested in Boston people or their problems.  

What are the problems? For me, it's not about race, it is about poverty. Towns like Boston reflect the two-tier society (at the very least) that we are creating. Boston and towns like it are an indictment of how working class people have been badly let down by the Conservatives and New Labour over the last thirty years. Whole towns are simply being left behind. Can we afford to allow whole boroughs to disengage from mainstream politics? Their 'ultimate solutions' might be even less palatable than the BNP.

Now, can I eat all the pies, please?

16 comments:

  1. It is not about race but that is how people express feeling uneasy in their own home. Why are people so scared to talk about it??? Call me racist 'till you're blue in the face. There is only so many immigrants a community can absorb before the community itself becomes dilute. My father fought in a war so a load of strange and foreign people could not just walk into his country and tell him how to live his life or change his ways. The fact is, this has happened to some communities in peace time and with the blessings of a Labour government Joe (not conservative!). When simple working class folk express their anxiety about change that is rapid and overwhelming to them, they are always accused of being racist. In cases of catastrophy where huge numbers of people migrate, these are always distressing times and the movement itself CAUSES the poverty you are speaking of. I hope people take action and don't sit back and put up with a situation they have not caused nor do they deserve! I am part foreign and I have worked in the inner city, I have seen things that would make an English person choke with anger for several reasons.
    But you see so many of us talk about Democracy, but the fact is when Joe Bloggs expresses his opinion of "send them back where they came from", staight away he is hushed as a racist, or as Gordon Brown put it "she was a bigoted woman". One man-one vote- my a"@e!!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Teresa, which side was your father fighting on?

    ReplyDelete
  3. My dad was English, I'm a half breed. 2nd ww, that's how he met my mum, during the Greek civil war, just after the Germans left Greece.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Teresa,

    'strange and foreign?' 'dilute what?' The strength of a nation should not come from mythological racial purity but from the values the community lives by.

    The fact is that much of the 'simple working class' rhetoric is racist. What is important is that it hides some legitimate concerns and they are not taken seriously. What the post is trying to suggest is that the concerns are much more about poverty than race and relate to all the 'communities' in Boston.

    There are a few people doing very well out of the situation in Boston while many are being exploited. Those exploiting the situation must love the race element taking attention away from the true causes.

    Democracy should be inclusive - nationalism, racism and the type of us and them arguments you are talking about excludes people - not a very healthy way to deal with problems. As the Auschwitz post illustrated, we know where that type of thinking leads.

    Exactly what was the 'historical lesson' from the Holocaust that you kept saying was so important? I'm baffled.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think we are more in agreement on this one than you think we are. When I say dilute, I mean destroy the best of a culture. Each culture has it's good and not so good elements. Clearly, an injection of new people and ideas is nearly always good (see how great civilisations have grown around areas where travel and mixing with others is easy and readily available), however, a sudden influx of people with very different ways and in huge numbers will cause stress for the local population as well as for migrants/immigrants themselves. It can break down the modus operandi of a community. We rely on a common culture to run a society smoothly, you can't just have people living in a situation where they don't know what the done thing is. That is chaos, not multiculturalism. I have seen at both ends. English people coming to Greece and sunbathing semi nude without consideration or permission and then being so thick as to complain of sexual harassment and sexual assult! At the other end of Europe (England) an Ikea sale which decended into a riot and police had to be called in to break it up, because people were not prepared to sit in line. This was in London, the footage showed (upsetting as this is for me to admit) and overwhelming ethnic group of people, who clearly (born in the UK or not!)were not Anglisided enough to behave as we do over here. I've lived in a country where there is no queuing, it is very distressing indeed.
    When I came over to lice in the UK, I suffered badly from culture shock, but it was the thought that this was my choice and I had to learn to live with it or go back where I came from. In the end I focused on the things that are much better over here and I stopped looking at Greece through rose tinted specticals. I've adjusted, I stop at red lights, I queue, I say please and thank you. When England play football, I support England! When we showed an England vs Brazil match at school in Bristol, the OVERWELMING majority of ethnic students were supporting Brazil!!! How back to front is this??? Why would a Jamaican, a Pakistani or a Somali support Brazil??? They don't even know where it is on the map? But they live here. Now this would not happen in America. They demand the loyalty of their people regardless of faith or colour. What say you?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Teresa, I think we are further apart than you think.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Possibly. I have no bone to pick with any race or nation. I just have seen the pain and upset that change can cause to people, often it is the outward difference of race that gets blamed. It's just about being outside your comfort zone. And for this to happen to you in your own home town when you have not asked for it, it's hard. Government should listen to it's people and take their complaints seriously instead of brushing off serious complaints as "racism". Polish people are not even a different race, but their huge numbers are upsetting people. There is a fine line between nationalism and plain feeling unwanted and unwelcomed in your own village!
    It's no skin off my nose because I'm adaptable and love meeting new people, but many feel they are walking down a street they don't even recognise even though they have walked the same street all their life.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Also, I'm happy with the Polish thing, the catholic churches are full and the collection plate also. Happy days!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Fascinating blog Joe - I always had the impression, partly from what you have told me in the past, that Boston was an isolated, insular community. And also heard what a bunch of fat b*****ds they were. Can imagine the chaos this sort of rapid immigration would cause both to infrastructure (schools, hospitals etc) and to the daily lives of most. As for the racism angle I believe we are all inhgerently racist to a degree (in that you look after your own, ie family, friends and any new group coming in taking work, whether you wanted it or not, and upsetting your way of life is bound to cause resentment and anger) so this sort of influx will always cause ill feeling. There is a limit to what a small town can take

    Interesting read - thank you

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks Kitey, I won't be able to go home again now.

    As for racism - I agree, I've always really disliked the English.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Racism is such a strong word and should be kept for clear cases of people being discriminated on the basis of race. If someone IS taking your job, IS using up precious resourses and IS threatening your way of life, then I think people have a genuine complaint to take to government and they should ask questions of why and how this was allowed to happen. The fact is that the stupid benefit system is now being addressed and hopefully there won't be this culture of money for the asking. But now that the perpetual benefit seeker is going to be forced (about time) to go back to work, what job will he do?

    ReplyDelete
  12. As for the jokes about the English, they rarely amuse me. It is one of the few allowed forms of "racism". English bashing, ginger bashing and of course American bashing, these are allowed even in our "political correcteness gone mad" society. I have found the English very tolerant of my Greekness and my loudness etc. The English are far too polite to be openly racist, most of the time. We have seen nothing but isolated cases of race based violence in this country and no real extreem right wing organisations. No body realy aknowledges this about the English. People from 40 or 50 yrs and older have witnessed a radical transformation of their country in their life time and a radical transformation of belief systems and they have adapted admirably in their overwhelming majority.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Teresa,

    so much to disagree with.

    as someone who is English I can't figure out how my 'joke' can be racist. It's like Woody Allen telling a Jewish joke.

    'Too polite to be openly racist'. This is nonsense. Also are you suggesting that they are secretly racist?

    You should speak to Prof Eatwell at Bath Uni about the extent of extreme racist groups in this country. In my experience they are pretty active in the East Mids and East London, two places I have lived for long periods. The racist violence is not isolated and it is organised.

    Finally, I find your racial stereotyping of the 'English' deeply offensive. How dare you characterise the English as 'far too polite' I'm English and I'm not polite at all.

    ReplyDelete
  15. You are right on most of your points.
    True, you are not polite, but that is more about you and not the nation as a whole.
    Too polite to show how uncomfortable they might be feeling, that's all.
    It's not like Woody Allen telling a Jewish joke because you have repeatedly distanced yourself from the English before so clearly you don't feel you belong, where as Woody Allen clearly feels Jewish.
    As for the organised racist groups I know little about, but I have taught Somali kids who have fled Holland and have come here for some peace and quiet. There, it was aparently gorvernment policies that drove them away. So I can only presume we are better at tolerance than the Dutch. And I can bring examples for the French and Germans, and it seems that we are doing better than them. And I can guarantee you that we are light years ahead of the Greeks.
    That's all for now.

    ReplyDelete
  16. THe English are not the most racist people in Britain even, let alone Europe. I used racist in my previous comment in a term to denote opposition to different groups, whether they be the same race or not (admittedly a lazy use of the word - apologies). As for anti-English jokes it is hard to pick on the English for most things as they are practically perfect, the Americans on the other hand...

    ReplyDelete